Did Brzezinski suggest shooting down Israeli jets?

Former National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski suggested how the U.S. might respond should Israeli jets overfly Iraq on their way to bomb Iran.

Monday, September 28, 2009

By Adam Abrams

Article Tools

Discuss

In a recent interview with the Daily Beast last week, Zbigniew Brzezinski, the National Security Adviser from the Carter administration and erstwhile adviser to President Barack Obama, made a highly contentious statement regarding the U.S.-Israeli alliance. When asked how the U.S. would respond to Israeli jets using Iraqi airspace in order to stage an attack on Iran, Brzezinski was quoted as saying: “We are not exactly impotent little babies. They have to fly over our airspace in Iraq. Are we just going to sit there and watch? ... We have to be serious about denying them that right. That means a denial where you aren’t just saying it. If they fly over, you go up and confront them. They have the choice of turning back or not. No one wishes for this but it could be a Liberty in reverse.”

“A liberty in reverse” is a reference to the controversial encounter between Israeli jets and the American vessel U.S.S. Liberty in 1967 that resulted in the sinking of the U.S. Navy ship.

Brzezinski who is said to have a reputation for such rhetoric, found his calls for “a Liberty in reverse” dimly viewed by many in Jewish leadership.

For example, Anti-Defamation League national director Abraham H Foxman, responded to Brzezinski’s quip with this: “Here is an international legal expert and he doesn't even know that the US does not control sovereignty over Iraqi airspace. Putting that aside, Zbigniew Brzezinski has always had a nasty streak when it came to Israel…. it is better that we can now see it, and it is out in the open.”

The Obama administration quickly distanced itself from any association with Brzezinski quite some time ago. Former Ambassador Dennis Ross, senior adviser on Middle East affairs to the Barack Obama campaign, told New Jersey Jewish News in October of 2008, “Brzezinski is not an adviser to the campaign… there is a lot of disinformation that is being pushed, but he is not an adviser to the campaign. Brzezinski came out and supported Obama early because of the war in Iraq. A year or so ago they talked a couple of times. That’s the extent of it, and Sen. Obama has made it clear that on other Middle Eastern issues, Brzezinski is not who he looks to. They don’t have the same views.”

Adam Abrams reports on international issues.

Filed under iraq, us politics, iran, democrat, israel, diplomacy, war, nuclear

Middle East

Featured

World alarm over Syria's torture of children
A United Nations panel today voiced deep concern about massive human rights violations in Syria, including the reported torture of children, as the Government?s violent crackdown against protesters continues. more
TURKEY - Erdogan's religious acrobatics: Nicaea council church back to being a mosque
The church of Aghia Sophia in Nicaea (Izmit), in which the 787 Council was held, was used as a museum. A controversial decision by the Directorate General of Religious Affairs transforms it into a Muslim place of worship. Erdogan' contents Islamic sectors of society. more
Iraq: US Catholic bishops visit tomb of martyred priests
more
Lebanon: Carmelite monastery tries to stem the tide of emigration
more
IRAQ - Double targeted killings against the Christian community in Kirkuk
Yesterday in the district of Muthana, an armed group assassinated the 30 year old Catholic Bassam Isho. October 1, Emmanuel Polos Hanna, was found at the edge of the road to Baghdad shot to death. Christian sources in Kirkuk: "The attacks continue, in the total silence of the world." more
Anatomy of fear: A Sunni democracy in defence of Christians
The Lebanese commentator Elie Fayad questions the political prospects of Arab spring and Christians fears of radical Islamic tendencies: "Is it not time the East give a chance to Sunni democracy?". more
Catholic bishop of Wales endorses Jerusalem churches statement on Palestine
more
Christian priests and bishops come out in support of Palestinian statehood
more
Seaside fortress was a final stronghold of early Islamic power
Ancient harbor at Yavneh-Yam was used for hostage exchange, says Tel Aviv University researcher. more

Comments

Popular Right Now

Alyssa Bustamante, teen murderer, sentenced to life
The murderer faces the possibility of parole, and avoided confinement with adult criminals.
Life imitates art for drunken singer Randy Travis
Randy Travis, country crooner, sought solace at a local church following a fight with his girlfriend.
Teen murderer's diary reveals delight in killing nine-year-old girl
Alyssa Bustamante is awaiting sentence for the 2009 murder of a playmate.
Tone-deaf Obama reaps criticism for contraception mandate
Erstwhile Obama administration officials are holding back campaign support over the Chief Executive's decision to force Catholic hospitals to provide contraception for employees.
Online petition against Obamacare gains momentum

Popular Commentary

Obama adds insult to injury to Americans
Obama has put an end to the American Experiment
Hedonism has become America's official religion.
Obama has officially ended the American Experiment
Hedonism has become America's official religion.
On St Valentine's Day it is time to reflect on love
On St. Valentine's Day, let us examine our consciences and reflect upon our behavior towards others. Seek the source of Love.
Obamacare is about the lust for abortion
Obama would like nothing bettert than to force all religious institutions to provide abortion coverage. But the foremost issue is religious liberty.

New Reports

Growing tensions between Sudan and South Sudan
Obama may reach 'accomodation' over contraception mandate
Brazil to prosecute six men in connection with murder of native people
Guarani communities are frequently the target of Brazilian ranchers and foresters.
Vatican symposium on sexual abuse underscores reforms made by Pope Benedict
Alyssa Bustamante, teen murderer, sentenced to life
The murderer faces the possibility of parole, and avoided confinement with adult criminals.

New World News

Pakistan: Short stories in Punjabi, to promote Christian values and common good
Fr. Mukhtar Alam has published a volume of stories of his mother. Stories that give "light" to those who are in the "dark" and teach the common good. At presentation, near the cathedral of Faisalabad, intellectuals, writers and leaders of the Church of Pakistan Muslim.
Hong Kong: Hong Kong, jobs emergency: workers shortage by 2018
One government study confirms need for 14 thousand workers by 2018 to maintain economic growth at current levels. Behind this there are restrictive policies on birth control imposed by Beijing and the decision not to give citizenship to those born in the Territory.
Myanmar: Monk Gambira, leader of the Saffron Revolution, free again
The authorities had yesterday detained him "for questioning". First released only a month ago, Gambira has spent the past three years in prison for leading protests by monks against the Burmese government.
India: Karnataka: Jesuits and schools targeted by Hindu nationalists
Three attacks since 2011 at St. Joseph's PU College, Anekal. The religious are accused of not having displayed the national flag on Republic Day, but the president has always denied this. Silence of police and authorities. Sajan George, president of the Global Council of Indian Christians (GCIC): ...
Syria: Rebels claim and then deny responsibility for Aleppo attacks
At least 28 killed and 240 wounded in explosion of two car bombs at two military sites. Civilians among the victims. For the experts, the attack is a sign of the training that Free Syrian Army receives from abroad.

RSS

Twitter

Facebook

Google+
Submit a tip
Advertise
Terms of use
Privacy Policy
Contact